Das bereits am 8.11.1913 und 23.11.1913 besprochene Buch erfährt auch in The Courier-Journal Nr. 16404 (Louisvill, Kentucky) auf S. 8 eine Würdigung:

"              MUSICAL INTERESTS

     To his series, Symphonies and Their Meaning, Philip Goep [sic] now adds a third volume, Modern Symphonies. With an essay of general character he begins these studies–The Symphony During the Nineteenth Century. This is followed by chapters of analysis and interpretation devoted to Berlioz and Liszt, to [... sechs Namen ...], Sibellius [sic], Bruckner, Hugo Wolff, Richard Straus [sic], Sgambati and Martucci. [... Elgar und vier amerikanische Komponisten ...]. The student will find the volume helpful, though it may be hoped that he will not quote some of the more saccharine phrases of description. (J. B. Lippincott Co., Philadelphia)." (*).

The Manchester Guardian Nr. 21003 kündigt in einem Inserat auf S. 1 eine Aufführung des Quintetts am 8.12.1913 an:

"               MEMORIAL HALL, ALBERT SQUARE.

EDITH ROBINSON QUARTET.

     EDITH ROBINSON           LILY SIMMS.

     ISABEL McCULLAGH.    MARY McCULLAGH.

         FIRST CONCERT, MONDAY, Dec. 8, at 7 3 .

     Vocalist . . . . Mr. J. FRANCIS HARFORD

     Viola . . . . . . . . . . . . .  Mrs. C. R. BRIGGS.

     Oboe . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .  Mr. A. NICHOLS.

     Pianoforte . . . . . . . . . .  Mr. C. RISEGARI.

                          PROGRAMME.

Quintet–Bruckner . . . . . . .  Cantata–Bach

Quartet in C minor  . . . . . . . . . . .  Brahms

[... Tickets ... Subscription for Two Concerts 6s. ...]." (**).